Tim Alexander left Primus, citing lost passion and a new life path

ICYMI: Primus drummer Tim "Herb" Alexander recently left the band, sharing with Rolling Stone that the decision stemmed from a profound shift in his priorities. After decades behind the kit with the experimental rock trio, Alexander admitted he no longer felt the passion that had once driven him. He explained that while he felt strong and healthy, ongoing aches and an awareness of needing to balance life differently motivated his departure​.

It's a lot like a quote from psychoanalyst Erik Erikson: "The richest and fullest lives attempt to achieve an inner balance between three realms: work, love and play." Alexander, who first joined Primus in 1989 and contributed significantly to their unique, genre-redefining sound blending funk, rock, and progressive influences, reflected on how the demands of extensive touring affected him. The 58-year-old highlighted the toll drumming has taken on his body, mentioning chronic pain and a history of heart issues, including a significant heart surgery in 2014 following a minor heart attack​.

He candidly discussed how playing for so many years, something initially rooted in passion, began to feel more like a job, impacting his physical health, mental well-being, and family life. It was not really working for him, so, in recent months, he focused on recovery and introspection, recognizing the need for change to sustain both personal happiness and familial relationships​. Apparently, quitting Primus was deemed necessary for his resiliency.

In his departure message to Primus, Alexander expressed heartfelt gratitude and admiration for his bandmates, underscoring that his choice was made with care and affection. Despite the abrupt nature of his exit, Primus, led by bassist and vocalist Les Claypool and guitarist Larry "Ler"
LaLonde, respected his decision. They have since prepared to continue performing, including upcoming shows featuring special guest drummers (hopefully without any Spinal Tap moments).